I think that I have said it before, but I want to say again, I think it is wonderful when people give step by step instructions on what is supposed to be done in a classroom. After reading this, I feel that I could really help someone understand how a multigenre project should be implemented in a classroom. I know that they had and example of a teacher’s second grade project, but I think that is a little much for a second grader. I am happy to have one decent writing about a subject from my second grade classroom. I think that it would be difficult and very time consuming to require more than two genres for one particular content area. I do like exposing children to different genres. I think that it would be much easier for me to pick different subject matters for a specific genre.
There was also a lot of group collaboration that was integral for the understanding and completion of the assignment. I like putting the project on the student and then they have a real sense of accomplishment and learn problem solving, cooperation, and general thinking skills as well as about their subject and genres. This seemed to be such an important part, and I felt that my second graders do well to stay on task without a teacher for about 5-8 minutes. After that, the conversation tends to not be on task. I am not saying that it can not be done, but I feel that it would be a definite challenge. I have completed a multigenre project and was not aware of it until now. I still remember the project and some of the things we completed for a high school English class. I do not remember a lot of assignments from school and think that it is interesting that once I started reading about multigenre that this particular project really stood out in my mind and brought back a lot of fond memories. I remember my classmates and I preparing for the presentation of our project. I think that I is a gift tot be able to learn for a lifetime and that is what I did with that particular project.
Multigenre projects would have to be memorable to a student just because it is so different from what they are used to doing. Teacher, including myself, must think about what is going to be the greatest impact for our students.
Project Idea
I might do my multigenre project on Abraham Lincoln. I think that he and his life are fascination and ideas for several genre have come to my mind:
Letters from or to him
News article about his death
Calendar or schedule of what he might do
Journal entry of his, his wife, or John Wilkes Booth
List of things he might need to get completed in a day
Poem
Invitation to the play
Election Poster (or whatever form of advertisement they used)
Banner about his election
Story about his loss of the ?congressional election?
Sign to advertise to fight in the Civil War
Eye witness account of assassination
I am sure there are many more
There are a lot of ideas that I have but have not done research and will need to see what will work best with the information that I find.
I also thought about Harriet Tubman. She is an amazing woman and some of the same genre ideas can work for her too.
Recipe for a multigenre piece
several students to work cooperatively one interesting topic
6 (or more to taste) cups of previous genre motivated students and teacher
lots of time to work teacher direction
students to inquire
Preheat writing workshop for months before starting. Then have students pick a topic and work, work, work. Celebrate the final draft with a party to enjoy and share the project together.
I love it! The recipe is sooo neat (and true)!
Jennifer,
You have really thought about this. I think you are right. It is great to have specifics to help teachers get started. I think in 2nd grade you are going to have to model, model, model. You may be able to combine some teacher-directed activities with independent efforts. Abraham Lincoln is a great choice. There are so many options. One of the things I really like about multi-genre is the authentic texts that it incorporates. That’s what kids need to learn about in real life.
Mary B.